6 Ledyard Avenue
Cazenovia, New York
(315) 655-9232

The Brewster Inn

6 Ledyard Avenue

Cazenovia,  NY
(315) 655-9232


Homemade Pies  $9

Chocolate Cream Pie – Creamy custard, dark chocolate ganache

Blueberry – Local to CNY, Picked at the peak of ripeness

Lemon Meringue – Tart filling with fluffy meringue topping

Chocolate Raspberry Mousse Cake   $12

Chocolate mousse, raspberry compote,

chocolate buttercream & dark chocolate ganache

Passionfruit Custard   $10

Coconut milk ice cream, graham cracker tuile,

with a housemade tropical granola crunch

Pineapple Upside Down Cake   $10

Tropical Pekoe tea ice cream, roasted

Pineapple, & a spicy ginger caramel

Bananas Foster $10
Bananas flambeed in brown sugar, butter and liqueur over a 
crepe filled with vanilla ice cream

Creme Brulee $9
A rich custard topped with a contrasting layer of caramelized sugar

Brewster Mud Pie $9
Chocolate wafer crust filled with homemade cappuccino ice cream, decadently finished with fudge, whipped cream & slivered almonds

Homemade Ice Cream & Sorbet $8
Seasonal flavors include

Dulce de Leche, 

Raspberry Mascarpone,


Smokey Jalapeño Candied Bacon

& seasonal sorbet selections

Grand Marnier Souffle $12

Light and fluffy, topped with powdered sugar & vanilla anglaise 

(Please allow 15-20 minutes to prepare)


Whole pies ($20) and pints of ice cream ($6.50)

are also available for takeout via our gourmet market.